| 1 | Ronald DonkorNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 21 | 4.2 M € |
| 2 | Julian HallNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 18 | 3.8 M € |
| 3 | Jorge RuvalcabaNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 25 | 3.4 M € |
| 4 | Ethan HorvathNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Portar | 31 | 3.3 M € |
| 5 | Adri MehmetiNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 17 | 3.0 M € |
| 6 | Cade CowellNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 23 | 2.1 M € |
| 6 | Julián BazánNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 20 | 2.1 M € |
| 8 | Justin CheNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 22 | 1.6 M € |
| 9 | Matthew Dos SantosNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 18 | 1.6 M € |
| 10 | Dylan NealisNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 28 | 1.4 M € |
| 11 | Andy RojasNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 20 | 1.4 M € |
| 12 | Dennis NelichNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 18 | 1.2 M € |
| 13 | Mijahir JiménezNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 19 | 875 K € |
| 14 | Rafael MosqueraNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 21 | 850 K € |
| 15 | Emil ForsbergNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 35 | 800 K € |
| 15 | Omar ValenciaNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 22 | 800 K € |
| 17 | Cameron HarperNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 24 | 775 K € |
| 18 | Robert VoloderNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 25 | 750 K € |
| 19 | Tanner RosboroughNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 18 | 600 K € |
| 20 | Mohammed SofoNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 21 | 575 K € |
| 21 | Nehuén BenedettiNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 21 | 525 K € |
| 22 | AJ MarcucciNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Portar | 27 | 500 K € |
| 22 | Jahkeele Marshall-RuttyNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 22 | 500 K € |
| 24 | Juan José MinaNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 22 | 475 K € |
| 25 | Joyeux Masanka BungiNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 19 | 350 K € |
| 26 | David RuizNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Mijlocaș | 22 | 225 K € |
| 27 | Tim ParkerNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Fundaș | 33 | 200 K € |
| 28 | John McCarthyNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Portar | 34 | 150 K € |
| 29 | Eric Maxim Choupo-MotingNew York Red Bulls | New York Red Bulls | Atacant | 37 | 75 K € |