| 1 | Nicolás Fernández MercauNew York City FC |  New York City FC | Atacant | 26 | 15.0 M € |
| 2 | Bénie TraoréNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 23 | 8.8 M € |
| 3 | Agustin OjedaNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 22 | 5.2 M € |
| 4 | James SandsNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 26 | 3.0 M € |
| 5 | Hannes WolfNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 27 | 2.9 M € |
| 6 | Matt FreeseNew York City FC | New York City FC | Portar | 28 | 2.5 M € |
| 7 | Andres PereaNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 25 | 2.3 M € |
| 7 | Tayvon GrayNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 24 | 2.3 M € |
| 9 | Máximo CarrizoNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 18 | 1.7 M € |
| 10 | Aiden O'NeillNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 28 | 1.6 M € |
| 11 | CF Cooper FlaxNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 22 | 1.3 M € |
| 12 | Nico CavalloNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 24 | 1.2 M € |
| 13 | Raul GustavoNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 27 | 1.1 M € |
| 14 | Kai TrewinNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 25 | 1.1 M € |
| 14 | Kevin O'TooleNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 27 | 1.1 M € |
| 16 | Talles MagnoNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 24 | 1.1 M € |
| 17 | Jonathan ShoreNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 19 | 950 K € |
| 18 | Thiago MartinsNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 31 | 825 K € |
| 19 | Jacob ArroyaveNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 18 | 775 K € |
| 20 | Kevin PierreNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 23 | 725 K € |
| 21 | Max MurrayNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 24 | 700 K € |
| 22 | Alonso MartínezNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 28 | 675 K € |
| 23 | LuighiNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 20 | 600 K € |
| 23 | Mac LearnedNew York City FC | New York City FC | Portar | 24 | 600 K € |
| 25 | Tomás RomeroNew York City FC | New York City FC | Portar | 25 | 575 K € |
| 26 | Malachi JonesNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 23 | 525 K € |
| 27 | Keaton ParksNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 29 | 450 K € |
| 28 | Drew BaieraNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 19 | 425 K € |
| 29 | Arnau FarnósNew York City FC | New York City FC | Atacant | 23 | 400 K € |
| 29 | Kamran AcitoNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 22 | 400 K € |
| 31 | Matt MiazgaNew York City FC | New York City FC | Fundaș | 31 | 250 K € |
| 32 | Greg RanjitsinghNew York City FC | New York City FC | Portar | 33 | 175 K € |
| 33 | Maxi MoralezNew York City FC | New York City FC | Mijlocaș | 39 | 100 K € |
